eDiscovery

Above the Law Highlights a Conversation with CloudNine’s Brad Jenkins

Extract from Above the Law article by Zach Abramowitz

Today, I’m chatting with CloudNine’s CEO Brad Jenkins to find out more about his company’s story, their approach to the cloud and the future of the ediscovery space.

Zach Abramowitz: Brad, thanks for joining me, tell me a bit of the background behind your company. When did you decide to pivot into software?

Brad Jenkins: Great question and, like most software companies, we had both a tactical reason and a strategic reason for deciding to invest in building our software solution.

The tactical catalyst for our development was simply a 10,000 box scan project where the client asked us how they could best manage their data once it was digitized. From that request, we began developing a custom solution to solve a specific customer problem, and that launched us down the road of software development.

From a strategic perspective, as a litigation services and support company founded in 2002, we certainly were aware of the print-to-digital and digital-to-discovery challenges and opportunities presented to providers over the last decade. Initially, we helped clients address eDiscovery challenges by aggregating best-of-breed technology and supporting that technology with a strong portfolio of professional services. Over time, we became highly aware of the strengths and weaknesses of the leading software platforms and began to develop our technology to address the core needs expressed daily by our customers. Those needs being speed, simplicity, and security. Addressing those underserved needs, we launched our initial software platform which has evolved into our SaaS-delivered CloudNine Simplified eDiscovery Automation platform.

Read the complete conversation with Brad Jenkins on Above the Law.

CloudsNine_400x400_Transparent

CloudNine Voted as a Leading Online Review Platform Provider by Corporate Counsel Magazine Readers

National Survey of In-House Corporate Legal and Compliance Professionals Ranks CloudNine as Second Leading Online Review Platform

CloudNine, the eDiscovery Company (cloudnine.com) that empowers legal and business professionals with eDiscovery automation software and professional services that simplify litigation, investigations, and audits, today announced that it has been recognized as a leading online review platform according to the inaugural Best of Corporate Counsel reader ranking survey.

The Best of Corporate Counsel reader ranking survey was published in the July edition of Corporate Counsel Magazine. Voting for this inaugural survey was conducted via online ballot and limited to those working within in-house corporate legal and compliance departments. The ballot consisted of 55 categories, and more than 1,500 votes were cast in this inaugural run. CloudNine was highlighted in the 2016 survey as the second leading online review platform.

“As an eDiscovery technology company focused on simplifying eDiscovery through automation, we are excited that our offerings are positively impacting the way legal professionals conduct discovery, investigations, and audits,” shared Brad Jenkins, Chief Executive Officer of CloudNine. “We are incredibly grateful for the vote of confidence in CloudNine from eDiscovery professionals as highlighted in our ranking as a leading online review platform in the inaugural Best of Corporate Counsel reader ranking survey. We understand the importance of such a rating and are committed to continuing our singular focus of simplifying eDiscovery.”

Try CloudNine at No Risk, Immediately

To sign up for a free trial of CloudNine, visit the CloudNine website (cloudnine.com), request your free account, and begin immediately to use the power and precision of simplified eDiscovery automation in your litigation, investigation, and audits efforts.

About CloudNine, The eDiscovery Company

Founded in 2002 and based in Houston, Texas, CloudNine is a technology company with deep expertise in the analysis, processing, and review of electronically stored information (ESI). Currently used by more than 50 of the top 250 Am Law firms as well as in many of the world’s leading corporations, CloudNine has been highlighted in reports and surveys by Gartner, 451 Research, Blue Hill Research, and Corporate Counsel. CloudNine also publishes the eDiscovery Daily Blog, a trusted source of information for the legal industry.

A leader in eDiscovery automation, you can learn more about CloudNine by calling us at 713.462.3885, emailing us at info@cloudnine.com, or by visiting us online at cloudnine.com.

Press inquiries may be made to Chief Marketing Officer, CloudNine, via PR@cloudnine.com or 512-934-7531.

CloudsNine_400x400_Transparent

Inaugural Best of Corporate Counsel Survey Highlights CloudNine

Extract of survey from Corporate Counsel

The inaugural Best of Corporate Counsel reader ranking survey of top providers to the in-house corporate legal marketplace was published in the July edition of Corporate Counsel Magazine. Voting for this inaugural survey was conducted via online ballot and limited to those working within in-house corporate legal and compliance departments. The ballot consisted of 55 categories and more than 1,500 votes were cast in this inaugural run.

CloudNine was highlighted in the 2016 reading ranking survey as the second leading online review platform behind Relativity from kCura.

Source: Corporate Counsel Magazine

For access to the complete survey, click here.

CloudsNine_400x400_Transparent

Market Guide for E-Discovery Solutions: Mention of CloudNine By Gartner

Extract of report from Gartner Research

Authored by industry analyst Jie Zhang, and available for purchase from the Gartner website ($1,295.00), the new Market Guide for E-Discovery Solutions report provides information technology leaders and legal counsel considerations for the evaluation and selection of eDiscovery solutions. One of the areas highlighted in the report was eDiscovery Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) solutions.

Considerations for eDiscovery SaaS included:

  • Cloud e-discovery solutions are gaining momentum in the market with their ease of use, and more competitive and straightforward pricing structures.
  • Select e-discovery SaaS solutions strategically. Depending on the maturity of in-house e- discovery processes and teams, SaaS solutions may not be suitable for all matters.
  • When selecting the SaaS provider, it is important to understand their data center locations, among other things.

CloudNine was mentioned as a representative software provider in the Market Guide for E-Discovery Solutions. Key elements of CloudNine’s offering include:

  • SaaS Deployment Model
  • Processing, Analytics, Review, and Production
  • Private Cloud
  • Self-Service
  • Task and Process Automation (Fully Integrated)
  • Full Suite of Professional Services

Source: Gartner

For access to the complete report, click here.

CloudsNine_400x400_Transparent

Blue Hill Research Notes CloudNine in Modern eDiscovery Platform Report

Extract from article by Jim Duffy, Esq.

In order to assist organizations with their own eDiscovery solution selection and evaluation of eDiscovery vendor support for eDiscovery challenges, Blue Hill Research assembled a select Solution Landscape describing eDiscovery vendors that demonstrate strong adoption of modern eDiscovery solution components that include: (1) cloud-based deployment, (2) focus on expanded data collection, (3) robust predictive coding and analytics capabilities, and (4) improved user interface and user experience.

CloudNine received mention in the report Reinvesting in the eDiscovery Cycles: Modern eDiscovery Platforms and was noted as one of the vendors in the eDiscovery ecosystem that demonstrated attention to the challenges identified by Jim Duffy, Esq. of Blue Hill Research.

Source: Blue Hill Research

For access to the complete report, click here.

CloudsNine_400x400_Transparent

InsideCounsel Highlights 3 Reasons eDiscovery Companies Need Better Search Solutions

Extract from InsideCounsel article by Amanda Ciccatelli

With the amount of data being captured and stored by organizations doubling every 1.2 years, the ability to quickly and effectively search through data stores that are growing exponentially has become more important than ever to meet discovery obligations within reasonable costs.

There are three key reasons that law firms and e-discovery companies need better search solutions, according to [Doug] Austin [of CloudNine]. First, the ability to identify potentially relevant information in litigation quickly is key to determining the best course of action to proceeding in the case, and effective search is an important component to accomplishing that goal. Second, failure to preserve or produce clearly responsive electronically stored information (ESI) in litigation can lead to sanctions by the court.  And third, in a recent survey, budgetary constraints was identified as the factor to have the most impact on e-discovery business over the next six months, so search solutions help manage and control discovery costs to help litigants stay within reasonable budgets.

Austin shared three ways to address these issue including: Emphasize up-front information governance efforts to keep data volumes manageable and also identify all potential sources of data through an organization data map; emphasize automation of repeatable tasks within the discovery life cycle and select providers who can support that automation effort and help the organization reduce costs through reduction of personnel; and require their providers to offer predictable pricing models so that they can accurately estimate costs.

Source: Inside Counsel

For the complete article, click here.

CloudsNine_400x400_Transparent

Brad Jenkins of CloudNine Discovery – eDiscovery Trends

This is the first of the 2013 LegalTech New York (LTNY) Thought Leader Interview series.  eDiscoveryDaily interviewed several thought leaders at LTNY this year and generally asked each of them the following questions:

  1. What are your general observations about LTNY this year and how it fits into emerging trends?
  2. If last year’s “next big thing” was the emergence of predictive coding, what do you feel is this year’s “next big thing”?
  3. What are you working on that you’d like our readers to know about?

Today’s thought leader is Brad Jenkins of CloudNine Discovery.  Brad has over 20 years of experience as an entrepreneur, as well as 14 years leading customer focused companies in the litigation support arena. Brad also writes the Litigation Support Industry Blog, which covers news about litigation support and e-discovery companies’ funding activities, acquisitions & mergers and notable business successes. He has authored many articles on document management and litigation support issues, and has appeared as a speaker before national audiences on document management practices and solutions.  He’s also my boss!   🙂

What are your general observations about LTNY this year and how it fits into emerging trends?

Well, clearly the technology assisted review/predictive coding wave is the most popular topic here at the show.  I think I counted at least six sessions discussing the topic and numerous vendors touting their tools.  And, this blog covered it and the cases using quite a bit last year.  I’m sure you’ll hear that from a lot of the folks you’re interviewing.

Another trend that I’m seeing is integration of applications to make the discovery process more seamless, especially the integration of cloud-based collection and review applications.  We have an alliance with BIA and their TotalDiscovery legal hold and collection tool, which can export data into our review application, OnDemand®, which our clients are using quite successfully to collect data and move it along the process.  I think the “best of breed” approach between an application that’s focused on the left side of the EDRM model and one that’s focused on the right side is an approach that makes sense for a lot of organizations.

If last year’s “next big thing” was the emergence of predictive coding, what do you feel is this year’s “next big thing”?

I’m not sure that I see just one thing as the “next big thing”.  I certainly see the continued focus on integration of applications as one big thing.  Another big thing that I see is a broadening acceptance of technology assisted review from more than just predictive coding.  For example, clustering similar documents together can make review more efficient and more accurate and we provide that in OnDemand through our partnership with Hot Neuron’s Clustify™.

Perhaps the biggest thing that I see is education and adoption of the technology.  Many lawyers still don’t actively use the technology and don’t find the applications intuitive.  We’ve worked hard to make OnDemand easy to use, requiring minimal or no training.  A lot of vendors tout their products as easy to use, but we’re backing our claim with our free no risk trial of OnDemand that includes free data assessment, free native processing, free data load and free first month hosting for the first data set on any new OnDemand project.  We feel that we have a team of “Aces” and a hand full of aces is almost impossible to beat.  So, the free no risk trial reflects our confidence that clients that try OnDemand will embrace its ease-of-use and self-service features and continue to use it and us for their discovery needs.

What are you working on that you’d like our readers to know about?

In addition to our integration success with BIA, our partnership with Clustify and our free no risk trial, we’re also previewing the initial release of the mobile version of OnDemand.  The first mobile version will be designed for project administrators to add users and maintain user rights, as well as obtain key statistics about their projects.  It’s our first step toward our 2013 goal of making OnDemand completely platform independent and we are targeting a third quarter release of a new redesigned version of OnDemand that will support that goal.

Thanks, Brad, for participating in the interview!

And to the readers, as always, please share any comments you might have or if you’d like to know more about a particular topic!

Disclaimer: The views represented herein are exclusively the views of the author, and do not necessarily represent the views held by CloudNine Discovery. eDiscoveryDaily is made available by CloudNine Discovery solely for educational purposes to provide general information about general eDiscovery principles and not to provide specific legal advice applicable to any particular circumstance. eDiscoveryDaily should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a lawyer you have retained and who has agreed to represent you.

Announcing Third Annual LTNY Thought Leader Series! – eDiscovery Trends

The jumping light bulb can only mean one thing: It’s time for another thought leader interview series!

In our efforts to continue to bring our readers perspectives from various thought leaders throughout the eDiscovery community, eDiscoveryDaily has published several thought leader interviews over the nearly 2 1/2 years since our inception.  The last two years at LegalTech New York (LTNY), we were able to conduct interviews with several eDiscovery industry thought leaders and announced the schedule for those interviews after the show.  Click here to see the schedule for last year’s interviews and here to see the schedule for 2011’s interviews with links in each schedule to each interview we conducted.

The LTNY Thought Leader interviews are firmly established as a tradition, as we were able to conduct interviews for the third year in a row with several industry thought leaders!  We’re pleased to introduce the schedule for the series, which will begin next Monday, February 11.

Here are the interviews that we will be publishing over the next few weeks:

Monday, February 11: Brad Jenkins, President and CEO of CloudNine Discovery.  Brad has over 20 years of experience as an entrepreneur, as well as 14 years leading customer focused companies in the litigation support arena. Brad has authored many articles on litigation support issues, and has spoken before national audiences on document management practices and solutions.

Thursday, February 14: Ray Zwiefelhofer, President at World Software Corp. (Worldox).  Ray has over twenty years of experience within the technology and legal services market, offering professional, consulting, technology management and product solutions with an emphasis on working with AMLAW 250 & Fortune 500 organizations.

Friday, February 15: Tom Gelbmann, Principal Analyst of Gelbmann & Associates and co-founder of the Electronic Discovery Reference Model (EDRM) and Apersee.  Since 1993, Tom has helped law firms and Corporate Law Departments realize the full benefit of their investments in Information Technology.

Monday, February 18: Don Philbin, President and Founder of Picture It Settled®.  Don is a nationally recognized attorney-mediator, holds both a law degree and an MBA, mediates individual and class matters, and teaches courses at Pepperdine Law’s Straus Institute for Dispute Resolution.

Thursday, February 21: Laura Zubulake, Plaintiff in the landmark Zubulake vs. UBS Warburg case.  Laura is also the author of Zubulake’s e-Discovery: The Untold Story of my Quest for Justice, previously discussed on this blog here.

Friday, February 22: Alon Israely, Manager, Strategic Partnerships, Business Intelligence Associates (BIA).  Alon has over seventeen years of experience in a variety of advanced computing-related technologies and currently leads the Strategic Partner Program at BIA.

Monday, February 25: George Socha, President of Socha Consulting LLC and co-founder of the Electronic Discovery Reference Model (EDRM) and Apersee.  As President of Socha Consulting LLC, George offers services as an eDiscovery expert witness, special master and advisor to corporations, law firms and their clients, and legal vertical market software and service providers in the areas of electronic discovery and automated litigation support.

Thursday, February 28: Nigel Murray, Managing Director, Huron Legal.  Nigel has been at the forefront of the litigation support and e-Disclosure industry in the UK since 1991. He managed the first e-Disclosure project to go before a UK court in the early 2000’s and has since advised and worked with a large number of clients in the UK, mainland Europe and the Middle East in a range of industry sectors.

Friday, March 1 and Monday March 4 (Two Part Interview): Ralph Losey, Partner and National eDiscovery Counsel for Jackson Lewis, LLP.  Ralph is also an Adjunct Professor at the University of Florida College of Law teaching eDiscovery, a prolific author of eDiscovery books and articles, the principle author and publisher of the popular e-Discovery Team® Blog and the creator of the Electronic Discovery Best Practices (EDBP.com) model.

Wednesday, March 6 thru Friday, March 8 (Three Part Interview): Craig Ball, Law Offices of Craig D. Ball, P.C.  Craig has delivered over 600 presentations and papers to continuing legal and professional education programs throughout the United States.  Craig’s articles on forensic technology and electronic discovery frequently appear in the national media.  He also writes a monthly column on computer forensics and eDiscovery for Law Technology News and publishes a blog called “Ball in your Court“.

Thanks to everyone for their time in participating in these interviews, especially during a busy LegalTech week!

So, what do you think?  Please share any comments you might have or if you’d like to know more about a particular topic.

Disclaimer: The views represented herein are exclusively the views of the author, and do not necessarily represent the views held by CloudNine Discovery. eDiscoveryDaily is made available by CloudNine Discovery solely for educational purposes to provide general information about general eDiscovery principles and not to provide specific legal advice applicable to any particular circumstance. eDiscoveryDaily should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a lawyer you have retained and who has agreed to represent you.

Waste Management Wants to Throw Away the Metadata – eDiscovery Case Law

In the case In Re: Waste Management of Texas, Inc., No. 06-12-00097-CV (Tex: Court of Appeals, Sixth Dist., Jan. 18, 2013), a Texas appeals court refused to grant Waste Management’s petition for writ of mandamus asks us to direct the trial court to withdraw its order to produce native, electronic format with all metadata.

This antitrust case between competing sanitation companies in Texas has had a lengthy discovery phase.  As noted in the opinion issued by Chief Justice Josh R. Morriss, III:

“In late 2009—in response to an order that compelled the production of various internal business records but reserved for a later decision the question of whether the production must include metadata—Waste Management produced responsive records in the format of its choice, Adobe portable document format an explicit exception in the order, the 2009 production excluded the records’ metadata. In September 2012, the trial court ordered Waste Management to produce similar information, but this time in its native, electronic format with all metadata.”

As a result, Waste Management petitioned for a writ of mandamus asking the 6th District Court of Appeals of Texas to direct the trial court to withdraw its order, claiming that :

  • “the 2012 discovery order requires disclosure of ‘trade secrets and proprietary, confidential information, to a direct competitor.’”;
  • “the order requires production of data outside the relevant geographic area and is thus an overbroad ‘fishing expedition.’”;
  • “(a) that the order is a ‘do over’ that requires Waste Management to review and redact the data a second time, (b) that it requires the production of metadata after metadata was relinquished earlier, (c) that it insufficiently specifies the form in which the data is to be produced, (d) that production in native format makes redaction impossible, and (e) that producing metadata in native format is more costly.”;
  • “the order contradicts an agreed scheduling order entered ten weeks before…to provide data for a time period of only September 1, 2005, through October 31, 2010”; and
  • the opposing party “should be responsible for the costs because a ‘do-over’ is an “extraordinary step”.

The court found that Waste Management “failed to introduce any such evidence” that the discovery order will disclose trade secrets and rejected their various claims, including undue burden claims.  With regard to the claim that the order is a ‘do-over’ and that the opposing party had not previously requested metadata, the court noted previous requests that contained the following instruction “Any and all data or information which is in electronic or magnetic form should be produced in a reasonable manner”.  Citing FED. R. CIV. P. 34(b) which requires “a form or forms in which it is ordinarily maintained or in a reasonably useable form or forms”, the court stated “We conclude Bray’s original instruction that the electronic discovery must be produced in a ‘reasonable manner is the functional equivalent of the Federal ‘reasonably useable form or forms.’”.

So, what do you think?  Was it appropriate to require production of metadata?  Please share any comments you might have or if you’d like to know more about a particular topic.

Disclaimer: The views represented herein are exclusively the views of the author, and do not necessarily represent the views held by CloudNine Discovery. eDiscoveryDaily is made available by CloudNine Discovery solely for educational purposes to provide general information about general eDiscovery principles and not to provide specific legal advice applicable to any particular circumstance. eDiscoveryDaily should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a lawyer you have retained and who has agreed to represent you.

Pro Football Players Aren’t the Only Ones with Talent – eDiscovery Trends

In football, each team member has responsibilities.  For example, the quarterback throws the football (and sometimes changes the plays at the line of scrimmage), the receivers catch the football, the offensive line blocks and the defense tackles the guy with the ball.  Each player has responsibilities that align with their talents.  Likewise, the members of a litigation team have responsibilities that align with their talents.  Now, the Electronic Discovery Reference Model (EDRM) has created a new tool to align talents with their associated tasks.

Last week, EDRM announced the release of the EDRM Talent Task Matrix diagram and spreadsheet. As noted in their press release, the Matrix, collaboratively developed by EDRM’s Jobs Project Team, is a tool designed to help hiring managers better understand the responsibilities associated with common eDiscovery roles. The Matrix maps responsibilities to the EDRM framework, so eDiscovery duties associated can be assigned to the appropriate parties.

The EDRM Talent Task Matrix Spreadsheet is available in XLSX or PDF format.  It shows the EDRM Stage and Stage Area, the Responsibility within each stage, followed by the various positions that have responsibilities within the eDiscovery life cycle, as follows:

  • CXO
  • Senior Attorney
  • Attorney
  • Paralegal
  • Litigation Support
  • Discovery Analyst
  • Document / Data Analysis
  • Forensic
  • Records Management
  • Information Technology
  • Review Lead
  • Review Quality Control

The Matrix shows a “Yes” for each responsibility that each position participates in the responsibility.  There are 130 responsibilities listed in the Matrix, covering the entire EDRM life cycle.

EDRM’s Talent Task Matrix represents the joint efforts of the entire EDRM Jobs Project Team, spearheaded by co-leaders Maria Montoya of Bryan University and Keith Tom. Wade Peterson of Bowman & Brooke LLP led the development of the Talent Task Matrix diagram.

Comments on the EDRM Talent Task Matrix Diagram and the EDRM Talent Task Matrix are now being accepted and can be posted at the bottom of the page here. The comment period continues until February 28.  It’s quite in-depth, so they might have to consider extending it.

Of course, when it comes to football, only one team can apply their talent best to accomplish their task – winning the game!  Congrats to the Baltimore Ravens – winners of Super Bowl XLVII!  Not even a power outage could keep them from accomplishing their goal.

So, what do you think?  Could this Matrix be useful to managing the resources in your litigation project?  Please share any comments you might have or if you’d like to know more about a particular topic.

Disclaimer: The views represented herein are exclusively the views of the author, and do not necessarily represent the views held by CloudNine Discovery. eDiscoveryDaily is made available by CloudNine Discovery solely for educational purposes to provide general information about general eDiscovery principles and not to provide specific legal advice applicable to any particular circumstance. eDiscoveryDaily should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a lawyer you have retained and who has agreed to represent you.